Saturday, March 14, 2009

Phase 3 Option 2

I looked at Box 4 folder 25 of Nadine Gordimer's early writings. The first story in the folder was an untitled story about WWII. This story was difficult for me to find anything that resembled her usual themes of social inequality and apartheid. However, in all of Gordimer's work she uses explicit metaphors, and lots of description. The story was of men who worked fixing the communication line during the war in Egypt. The men face a near death experience that eventually the come out of alive, however we get to witness first hand through Gordimer's writing what they were thinking and feeling and how they were preparing to die. Some of the men don't seem to care, others are concerned with strictly monetary things, and one said, "I am bitter, and I am afraid, because I know life, and i am loath to let it go" I thought that this was the most interesting statement of this short story. In my idea it breaks the norms of what Gordimer wrote about. She projects this unjust society in most of her work, but this main character seems to not want to let go of anything about it. He is constantly looking forward to getting out of the war and back to society, and wants to live his life.
The second short story I read was called "Babe". It had very obvious themes that related to apartheid. The story was of a young woman who was born from a black woman and a white Irish man in South Africa. Her mother died in childbirth and her white father raises her for awhile. The girl detests everything about her that is black. She dies her hair blond, powders her face, and paints her nails to hide their "blackness". She meets a man who treats her poorly but is none the less infatuated with her. While on vacation she catches him cheating on her with a white woman, and loses it for just a second. You hope that this is when she develops pride for herself, but she does not. The man sends her away calling her awful names. Eventually the girl finds another white man who has the same disgust/intrigue for her, and she tells herself in the mirror she isn't so bad. Gordimer uses the girl to show the horrible way some white people look upon the entire black population. They are intrigued. They need them to have a stable economy and do the work they do not wish to do--so they are intrigued by them. But a part of them despises them and believes they are all that is wrong with their society and put them down. It is an odd relationship that Gordimer has worked out perfectly between this woman and white men.

4 comments:

  1. AJ, could you talk more about how you see the character depictions in "Babe" necessarily related to apartheid? You've really got me intrigued.

    I didn't look closely at that story, but when I was sifting through her "Essays," I noticed that Gordimer's "Essay for 29 March 1946” seemed like a class assignment in which she had to argue “Why It is not satisfactory to say that the function of language is to communicate thought.” Her response seemed to argue for language as participatory self-expression over social or group identification.

    That got me wondering how much she might actually practice what she preached? What could she possibly mean by that, and did you recall seeing the same idea reflected in her other "Essays" or perhaps in some of her other stories or her play?

    -Dr. Graban

    ReplyDelete
  2. I thought that your description of the way that the white individuals treated black individuals in "Babe" was very interesting. It is disheartening that she never really seemed to discover pride in herself. I wonder if that is saying something about how the race views itself since she hated everything that was black about her? Or do you just feel that the reason why she hated her black attributes was due to the social constructions of white individuals? The story sounds very interesting. I too would like to understand how it relates to apartheid.

    ReplyDelete
  3. AJ--

    I think it's very cool that you're already able to pick up on some of Gordimer's key themes. With the first story, I find it very interesting that you think she breaks from her usual writing techniques. Why do you think she decided to do this with this particular subject? Based on your brief description of the story as well as Gordimer's ideas about unjust society, do you think it's possible that the fact that the men were in this situation in the first place could be a comment on the unjustness of the world? I don't know anything other than what you wrote, but it seems like it's screaming the idea that "life's not fair." I would be interested to learn a little more about the specific characters (their physical attributes, the personalities, etc). Is the audience supposed to like these men and sympathize with them? Do we think that some of them (in a way) deserve to be in this position? It would be interesting to know a little more about that.

    -Merey

    ReplyDelete
  4. I find the depiction of the white population's dependence on the black population to provide labor and keep the economy going while also despising and blaming societal problems on the black population intriguing. It's as though the white population gets the best of both ends: someone to do the undesirable jobs, and a convenient scapegoat.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.